Use of SRLs in Latin America

By Alejandro Ortiz of Gardere Arena y Robles, S.C.

As a result of the new check the box regulations, U.S. tax advisors are increasingly advising their clients to use a Sociedad de Responsabilidad Limitada ("SRL") in Latin America, rather than the more conventional Sociedad Anonima ("SA"). While SAs in most countries are considered to be per se corporations, U.S. taxpayers may elect to have SRLs treated by the U.S. taxing authorities as partnerships or branches. The U.S. federal income tax advantages of such an election are several, including the following:

From the standpoint of the local Latin American law, the implications of using an SRL as opposed to an SA are not substantial, since the SRL operates under the same general principals as the SA - (i) limited liability for the partners, (ii) deemed an entity separate from its partners, (iii) taxed as a per se corporation, (iv) can have varying types of interest and can issue debt, (v) may engage in any commercial activity that a per se corporation can engage in and can have a similar capital structure.

There are, however, some important differences between an SA and an SRL. First, a typical SRL is managed by the partners who can regulate, by way of a personal agreement, the manner in which the Board will operate. The partners have the same liability as the Board Members in an SA. Second, the partners of an SRL may not sell or pledge their interest in the SRL without prior approval by the other partners. Third, the SRL may not be publicly held and typically is limited in the number of partners. Fourth, the SRL is not as thoroughly regulated as the SA, making it more flexible when implementing certain transactions that may be barred by the SA statutory limitations. However, certain limitations make the use of an SRL more restrictive. For example, in Brazil, an SRL may not issue debentures. In Venezuela, the maximum authorized capital of an SRL may not exceed 2,000,000 Bolivares. In Mexico, an SRL may not engage in activities related to the finance sector, including banking, insurance and brokerage activities.

For all practical purposes, the SRL is treated in the same legal manner as the SA. The differences that exist relate to the relationship amongst the partners, rather than the relationship between the SRL and the government or third parties. The benefits of the check the box regulations, however, make the SRL an attractive alternative for those interested in doing business in Latin America.